Browse over 9,000 car reviews

The car horror more Aussies need to see: ANCAP crash test reveals damage of a relatively low-speed collision and puts the spotlight on big vehicles like Ram 1500, Toyota LandCruiser and Ford Ranger | Opinion

Commercial Best Commercial Cars Hatchback Best Hatchback Cars SUV Best SUV Cars Ute Best Ute Cars Safety Small Cars Family Car Family Cars Car News
...
Dom Tripolone
News Editor
22 Dec 2024
4 min read

Fifty kilometres per hour doesn’t sound fast, but it’s enough to leave a popular small car barely recognisable in a head-on collision.

I was invited by the Australasian New Car Assessment Program (ANCAP) to witness a crash test of a new version of the Suzuki Swift hatchback and the results were horrifying, but it is something more Aussies should witness. It was given a one star safety score with very poor results for adult and child occupant protection.

The test I saw is called the frontal offset crash test. It propels the car at 50km/h into a 1400kg trolley shaped like the front end of another car also travelling at 50km/h.

The collision takes in the driver’s side half of the front of the vehicle and is designed to replicate a head-on collision when a car veers into another lane.

It is a truly destructive recipe for what is the same speed as most suburban streets.

It wasn’t just the damage done to the vehicle, which was extensive, but the sound and visual explosion that accompanied it.

MG3 crash test.
MG3 crash test.

The test brought into sharp focus the dangers present on our roads not just at extreme speeds but at a relatively low pace, too.

It proved a car can turn into a weapon when placed in the wrong or distracted hands. It is something new drivers should be made to view more often and be part of the education process. There is no greater display of “your actions have consequences” than the crash test.

Especially when newer drivers generally buy cheaper, smaller and lighter vehicles, putting them at greater risk.

MG3 crash test.
MG3 crash test.

ANCAP boss Carla Hoorweg said previously smaller cars are at a disadvantage because of their physical size, which puts the ever-growing footprint of vehicles on Australian roads into perspective.

The Toyota RAV4, Australia’s best-selling non-ute, has grown by about 500mm in length, 150mm in width and 250mm in height, as well as being about 500kg heavier since its inception in the 1990s.

Even popular small cars such as the current Mazda3 hatchback now weigh more than 1400kg.

Hyundai i30 sedan crash test.
Hyundai i30 sedan crash test.

Australia’s best-selling vehicle for the past two years, the Ford Ranger, weighs well over two tonnes.

Now take into account the growing influx of jumbo SUVs and American pick-ups on Australian roads.

The Ram 1500 pick-up tips the scales at between 2500kg-2750kg unloaded depending on the variant, which is more than a 1000kg more than the impact trolley used in the crash test. It is a similar story for the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado and Toyota Tundra.

ANCAP told CarsGuide earlier this year it had concerns about the extra-large utes.

GWM Cannon Alpha crash test.
GWM Cannon Alpha crash test.

“We’ve definitely got concerns. There are a lot of community concerns we are fielding,” said Hoorweg.

“We’re looking at vehicles that are being designed for the US market, they’re not necessarily going to have a focus on pedestrian protection or vulnerable road-user protection, that’s not a focus in those regulations. So we know there’s going to be a gap there.”

For now, full crash tests of big utes are off the table for ANCAP due to the exorbitant costs of buying five vehicles of each model needed to conduct the different crash tests.

Hoorweg said crash tests might not give the best data anyway, as the vehicles’ size, weight and ride height mean they are likely to perform better in crash tests compared to smaller and lighter vehicles.

Dom Tripolone
News Editor
Dom is Sydney born and raised and one of his earliest memories of cars is sitting in the back seat of his dad's BMW coupe that smelled like sawdust. He aspired to be a newspaper journalist from a young age and started his career at the Sydney Morning Herald working in the Drive section before moving over to News Corp to report on all things motoring across the company's newspapers and digital websites. Dom has embraced the digital revolution and joined CarsGuide as News Editor, where he finds joy in searching out the most interesting and fast-paced news stories on the brands you love. In his spare time Dom can be found driving his young son from park to park.
About Author

Comments