Browse over 9,000 car reviews

EXPERT RATING
6.0

Likes

  • Agile and responsive
  • Exciting drive
  • Good road grip

Dislikes

  • Ill-fitting run-flat tyres
  • Costly repairs
  • Expensive servicing
Graham Smith
Contributing Journalist
29 Apr 2016
5 min read

The 1 Series gave aspiring owners a propeller badge but costs mount with the miles.

New

The blue-and-white spinner emblem of BMW has been one of the more desired badges on the Australian motoring landscape. With so many aspiring to own a BMW, the company expanded its model range so more could join the club.

The 3 Series, once the entry point, grew in size and the price increased so in 2004 out rolled the smaller, cheaper 1 Series, still packed with the features expected of a BMW.

Variants were numerous: practical hatches, sporty coupes and stylish convertibles powered by affordable four-cylinder petrol engines, economical diesels and sizzling sixes.

They all had the familiar and appealing dynamic style of the German brand with the bodies seemingly shrink-wrapped over the chassis. They looked fast standing still.

Engine options kicked off with a modest 1.6-litre, going up to more potent 1.8-litre and 2.0-litre fours, punchy 2.0 turbo diesels and on to a 3.0-litre turbo six.

Even the base four-cylinder models were sure-footed

Transmission choices were five and six-speed manual and six-speed automatic.

BMW's promise was a thrilling driving experience no matter the model, and the 1 Series was no different.

In common with BMWs of the time it was rear-wheel drive. Even the base four-cylinder models were sure-footed, agile and responsive, with the range-topping six-cylinder models providing the excitement.

One downside for some was the firm ride attributed to fitment of the run-flat tyres.

Now

As with any brand BMW is not immune from problems and breakdowns, particularly as the kilometres climb, and the early 1 Series odometers are now showing high readings.

Intending buyers should invest the time and cash to have a specialist in the brand thoroughly check a car.

The promise of a thrilling driving experience means that some BMWs are driven hard. They are well able to cope with that style of driving but it's best to shop around for a well-cared-for example.

Look for oil leaks around the engine, they can cost quite a bit to repair. Check also for leaks from the radiator and cooling setup, as BMW's plastic fittings break down over time and can be costly to replace.

Listen for clunks in the suspension when applying the brakes, or going over bumps, as these signify worn bushes.

It's worth befriending a BMW service specialist if you want to save on servicing and parts.

Expect relatively high brake wear and, post purchase, regular replacement of brake pads and disc rotors.

Servicing is advised by an indicator on the dash — make sure it's working correctly so you don't inadvertently miss services.

The service record preferably should show the work was done by someone familiar with the brand and its foibles.

It's worth befriending a BMW service specialist if you want to save on servicing and parts.

The run-flat tyres not only result in a firm ride that some people find uncomfortable but also are expensive to replace

Some owners fit conventional radials, which are more comfortable and more affordable. When they do they don't always fit a spare, so if you find a car with radials, check the boot for a fifth wheel.

BMW 120I 2004:

Engine Type Inline 4, 2.0L
Fuel Type Unleaded Petrol
Fuel Efficiency 7.9L/100km (combined)
Seating 5
Price From $4,290 - $6,380

Verdict

Smithy says

Great driving experience but high mileage cars can be expensive.

Owners say

Carol Toal I bought a 118i in 2005. I loved the look, the handling, the "get up and go". I didn't like the finish inside, the armrests on the doors wore, there was a problem with the headlight switch and there was a rattle in the dash the dealer couldn't fix. There was an oil leak after about 20,000km and the dealer "couldn't find" the cause of that until after the warranty ran out. What I really disliked was being offered only $9000 trade-in on a X1 when the 118i was eight years old, immaculate and with only 68,000km on the clock.

Andrew Collins I've had issues with headlights regularly blowing and oil leaks with my 2007 120i. It doesn't leave a puddle on the ground but I had to put oil in it every few weeks.

Robert Ingram The 116i handles well, is economical and cheap to run. I really like it.

Sophie Anstey The 118i does the job for us but I don't really like it. You feel all the bumps in the road and fixing the problems we've had with it has been expensive.

John Jensen Terrible, poorly put together, costs heaps to service, and dealers don't care. 

At a glance

Price new: $34,900-$44,100
Price now:
116i - $7000-$12,000
118i - $8500-$19,500
118d - $15,000-$21,000
120i - $7000-$21,000
120d - $10,500-$18,000
123d - $17,000-$24,000
125i coupe - $17,500-$32,000
135i convertible - $24,000-$42,000

Safety: 5 stars
Engines: 1.6-litre 4-cyl, 85kW/150Nm; 1.8-litre 4-cyl, 95kW/180Nm; 2.0-litre 4-cyl, 110kW/200Nm; 2.0-litre 4-cyl turbo diesel, 105kW/300Nm and 150kW/400Nm; 3.0-litre 6-cyl, 195kW/315Nm; 3.0-litre 6-cyl turbo, 225kW/400Nm
Transmissions: 5-speed man, 6-speed man, 6-speed auto; RWD
Thirst: 4.5L-8.6L/100km

Also consider

Honda Accord 2004-11 - 4 stars - Nice driver, comfortable and well built. A better long-term prospect. Pay between $3500-$22,000.

Mazda6 2004-11 - 4 stars - Attractive to look at, pleasant to drive, reliable to own. Pay between $3000-$23,000.

Audi A3 2004-11 - 3.5 stars - Chunky hatch sits well on the road but comes at a European cost. Pay between $3500-$29,000.

Coming up

Do you own or have you owned a Audi A1? Share your experience with other CarsGuide readers by sending comments to grah.smith@bigpond.com or write to CarsGuide, PO Box 4245, Sydney, NSW 2010.

Click here to see more BMW 1 Series pricing and spec info.

 

Pricing Guides

$9,095
Based on 10 cars listed for sale in the last 6 months.
LOWEST PRICE
$6,985
HIGHEST PRICE
$13,999
Graham Smith
Contributing Journalist
With a passion for cars dating back to his childhood and having a qualification in mechanical engineering, Graham couldn’t believe his good fortune when he was offered a job in the Engineering Department at General Motors-Holden’s in the late-1960s when the Kingswood was king and Toyota was an upstart newcomer. It was a dream come true. Over the next 20 years Graham worked in a range of test and development roles within GMH’s Experimental Engineering Department, at the Lang Lang Proving Ground, and the Engine Development Group where he predominantly worked on the six-cylinder and V8 engines. If working for Holden wasn’t exciting enough he also spent two years studying General Motors Institute in America, with work stints with the Chassis Engineering section at Pontiac, and later took up the post of Holden’s liaison engineer at Opel in Germany. But the lure of working in the media saw him become a fulltime motorsport reporter and photographer in the late-1980s following the Grand Prix trail around the world and covering major world motor racing events from bases first in Germany and then London. After returning home to Australia in the late-1980s Graham worked on numerous motoring magazines and newspapers writing about new and used cars, and issues concerning car owners. These days, Graham is CarsGuide's longest standing contributor.
About Author
Disclaimer: The pricing information shown in the editorial content (Review Prices) is to be used as a guide only and is based on information provided to Carsguide Autotrader Media Solutions Pty Ltd (Carsguide) both by third party sources and the car manufacturer at the time of publication. The Review Prices were correct at the time of publication. Carsguide does not warrant or represent that the information is accurate, reliable, complete, current or suitable for any particular purpose. You should not use or rely upon this information without conducting an independent assessment and valuation of the vehicle.
Pricing Guide
$6,985
Lowest price, based on third party pricing data.
For more information on
2008 BMW 1 Series
See Pricing & Specs

Comments