Alfa Romeo MiTo 2011 review

Why would you buy a small Italian car when there are some perfectly acceptable Japanese and Korean rivals for almost half the price? I actually don't have the answer because it's all to do with how an Alfa Romeo buyer ticks. Speak to these tragics and it's just the allure of Alfa - the smell of the leather, the sound of the exhaust, the feel of its tyres through corners, and the sense that it's a different car for a different personality.

Buyers also had the knack - in earlier Alfa experiments - of mind-numbing dismissal of some embarrassing quality issues and an irregular reliability record. Some things change. The latest Alfa small car, the Mito, delivers transport that is one step left of the norm - owners call it a character - but there are unanswerable questions as to why. Yes, it can be cute to some. But unlike its well-executed and smile-inducing big sister Giulietta, the Mito is flawed - especially in its new dual-clutch version.

VALUE

Yes, I know price is less a criteria than a desire by owners to prove they don't follow convention. There is a place in my world for these people, parked in the same room as those who fervently watch Home & Away. Alfa opens its Mito cabinet at a not insurmountable $29,990 for the manual. The test car is the TCT (twin-clutch transmission) at $2000 extra, $31,990.

Its Euro rivals include the Golf 90TSI (from $24,990), Polo GTI ($27,790), Renault Clio 200 ($36,490) and Alfa's Fiat-badged mechanical clone, the 500 Sport ($24,990). There's very strong competition here. But this doesn't dismiss the Mito's high level of features and even its decent build quality.

DESIGN

It's called cute by people who think pugs are the canine equivalent to Monica Belluci. No, the Mito isn't cute. It's just small. Styling cues are borrowed from other Alfa models - round tail lights, deep and narrow shield grille, and so on - but they're lumped onto a bulbous body that, in a previous article, I described as looking like Mr Potatohead with accessories. But it's functional and Italian and I bet that's one of the first times you've seen those two words in the same sentence.

TECHNOLOGY

The big news is the Multi-Air head that uses solenoids to control the intake valves. This allows the engine management system to dictate how long these valves remain open and even delay closure until much of the trapped cylinder air is expelled. That makes it very efficient.

The TCT's 1.4-litre turbo-petrol engine has 99kW/230Nm, down from the manual-transmission model's 114kW/230Nm. The manual doesn't have the Multi-Air head and posts a 6.5L/100km economy compared with the TCT's brilliant 5.5L/100km. Part of the TCT's fuel saving is that head but also the stop-start system. The six-speed gearbox is a twin-clutch arrangment with electronic engagement (hence no clutch pedal). It's variously called DSG, Powershift and S-tronic by other companies. Mitos also gets Electronic Q2 which maximises torque transfer to the front wheels, effectively electronically simulating a limited-slip differential.

Then there's Alfa's DNA program that gives drivers the choice of three modes - All Weather, Normal and Dynamic. All Weather is for snow bunnies, normal is for economy running and Dynamic is the only place you want to be if you have a heartbeat.

SAFETY

Top marks here with a five-star crash rating, electronic stability program, brake slip control, traction control, a hill holder, the Q2 electronic diff and seven airbags.

DRIVING

Every component of the Mito works hard to make you enjoy the ride. And the harder you push, the more responsive the car becomes. That's the essence of Alfa. The problem is that to get the most out of the car, you have to have the quiet winding road, the driving ability and the compunction to get out there and enjoy it. There's not much of that in Australia. Mito is also presented - and priced - as a city car and this marketing direction has blurred the little car's strengths. However, at least it's fun to drive when the conditions exist. As for the other conditions - city and suburbs - it's not entirely happy.

Sure, it gets around. But the visibility is poor so it relies on its parking sensors. The TCT has an uncomfortable pause between pressure on the accelerator pedal and actual movement that can really get your heartbeat going when crossing a busy road.

It should be driven only in its Dynamic mode. The Normal mode is too sluggish to enjoy. While we're on the subject of lag, the stop-start is commendable but has a restart time that is the slowest on the market. Add that to the gearbox lag and you have some interesting quiet times with yourself after the traffic light turns green.

The three-door almost, literally, shuts the door on this being suitable for hauling babies or toddlers. In fact the high waistine and tiny rear windows may make it a dark, claustrophobic hole for any child. Rather, this is a car the for enthusiast who has downsized.

VERDICT

It is the espresso of Alfa's cappuccino but the beans have a bitter after taste. It is enjoyable to drive when the road conditions are tights and twisty, or even when the freeway is running smoothly, but even the pseudo-automatic gearbox doesn't give much joy in the city.

The Mito gets high marks for its innovative technology that has real-world benefits, but its the box they come in that is flawed. On top of that, it's fighting one-armed with the cheaper, faster, more engaging and more practical Volkswagen Polo. Not this time, Alfa.

ALFA ROMEO MITO SPORT TCT

Price: $34,990
Warranty: 3 years, 100,000km, roadside assist
Resale: 65%
Service interval: 15,000km or 12 months
Economy: 5.5 l/100km; 128g/km CO2
Safety equipment: seven airbags, ESC, ABS, EBD, EBA, TC, hill assist
Crash rating: 5 star
Engine: 99kW/190Nm (230Nm available) 1.4-litre turbo-petrol
Transmission: Six-speed dual-clutch auto
Body: 3-door, 4 seats
Dimensions: 4063 (L); 1720mm (W); 1446mm (H); 2511mm (WB)
Weight: 1170kg
Tyres: 215/45R17, space-saver spare