Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Volkswagen Caddy 5 vs Toyota HiAce

What's the difference?

VS
Volkswagen Caddy 5
Volkswagen Caddy 5

$34,990 - $63,990

2023 price

Toyota HiAce
Toyota HiAce

$49,990 - $97,988

2023 price

Summary

2023 Volkswagen Caddy 5
2023 Toyota HiAce
Safety Rating

Engine Type
Turbo 4, 1.5L

Diesel Turbo 4, 2.8L
Fuel Type
Premium Unleaded Petrol

Diesel
Fuel Efficiency
6.4L/100km (combined)

8.2L/100km (combined)
Seating
2

2
Dislikes
  • No standard blind-spot monitoring (or rear cross-traffic alert)
  • Fiddly touchscreen
  • Poor engine-braking

  • Short service intervals
  • No fold-down inboard driver’s armrest
2023 Volkswagen Caddy 5 Summary

Australia’s small van class (under-2.5 tonne GVM) is a three-way fight between the Peugeot Partner, Renault Kangoo and Volkswagen Caddy Cargo.

All are well designed for light delivery work but in 2023 Germany’s sole contender enjoys a dominant lead over its French rivals.

Recent industry sales figures show the current Caddy 5 (or fifth-generation) range commands 74 per cent of sales. In other words, three out of every four new small vans sold in Australia are displaying a VW badge!

Clearly, the Caddy must be doing something (many things) right to maintain this level of dominance. We recently spent a working week with a petrol-powered Cargo, equipped with the latest MY23 safety upgrades, to find out why.

View full pricing & specs
2023 Toyota HiAce Summary

Toyota doesn't make hasty decisions and with good reason. As one of the world’s largest and longest-running automotive manufacturers (founded 1937), it applies the same rigorous assessment of each new model proposal or running change. 

That ensures each green light stacks up as a viable business case, from which the company is assured of getting a worthwhile return on its investment.

This pragmatic approach was evident in Toyota’s decision in 2022 to offer a rear barn-door option for its HiAce van. Given this iconic commercial vehicle was launched in 1967, it’s taken 55 years for Toyota to finally offer an alternative to the HiAce's signature swing-up tailgate. 

Barn doors are ideal for those needing forklift access to cargo bays, so we assume this decision was prompted not only by competitors offering similar options but also growing demand from Toyota’s all-important fleet buyers. We recently tested one to see if this long-awaited option is on the money.

View full pricing & specs

Deep dive comparison

2023 Volkswagen Caddy 5 2023 Toyota HiAce

Change vehicle