Browse over 9,000 car reviews

Car of the Year 2011 shortlist

Volkswagen Volkswagen News Volkswagen Scirocco Volkswagen Scirocco News Volkswagen Scirocco 2012 Volvo Volvo News Volvo S60 Volvo S60 News Volvo S60 2011 Land Rover Land Rover News Range Rover Evoque Range Rover Evoque News Land Rover Range Rover Evoque 2011 Hyundai Hyundai News Hyundai I40 Hyundai I40 News Hyundai I40 2011 Ford Ford News Ford Territory Ford Territory News Ford Territory 2011 BMW BMW News BMW 1 Series BMW 1 Series News BMW 1 Series 2011 BMW 118d BMW 118d News BMW 118d 2011 BMW 120i BMW 120i News BMW 120i 2011 BMW 123d BMW 123d News BMW 123d 2011 BMW 125i BMW 125i News BMW 125i 2011 BMW 135i BMW 135i News BMW 135i 2011 BMW 1M BMW 1M News BMW 1M 2011 BMW 116i BMW 116i News BMW 116i 2011 BMW 118i BMW 118i News BMW 118i 2011 Ford Focus Ford Focus News Ford Focus 2011 Nissan Nissan News Nissan Micra Nissan Micra News Nissan Micra 2011 Kia Kia News Kia Rio Kia Rio News Kia Rio 2011 Holden Holden News Holden Cruze Holden Cruze News Holden Cruze 2011 Convertible Best Convertible Cars Volkswagen Convertible Range Volvo Convertible Range Land Rover Convertible Range Hyundai Convertible Range Ford Convertible Range BMW Convertible Range Nissan Convertible Range Kia Convertible Range Holden Convertible Range Coupe Best Coupe Cars Volkswagen Coupe Range Volvo Coupe Range Land Rover Coupe Range Hyundai Coupe Range Ford Coupe Range BMW Coupe Range Nissan Coupe Range Kia Coupe Range Holden Coupe Range Hatchback Best Hatchback Cars Volkswagen Hatchback Range Volvo Hatchback Range Land Rover Hatchback Range Hyundai Hatchback Range Ford Hatchback Range BMW Hatchback Range Nissan Hatchback Range Kia Hatchback Range Holden Hatchback Range Sedan Best Sedan Cars Volkswagen Sedan Range Volvo Sedan Range Land Rover Sedan Range Hyundai Sedan Range Ford Sedan Range BMW Sedan Range Nissan Sedan Range Kia Sedan Range Holden Sedan Range SUV Best SUV Cars Volkswagen SUV Range Volvo SUV Range Land Rover SUV Range Hyundai SUV Range Ford SUV Range BMW SUV Range Nissan SUV Range Kia SUV Range Holden SUV Range Wagon Best Wagon Cars Volkswagen Wagon Range Volvo Wagon Range Land Rover Wagon Range Hyundai Wagon Range Ford Wagon Range BMW Wagon Range Nissan Wagon Range Kia Wagon Range Holden Wagon Range Car of the Year Car News
...
Paul Gover
7 Dec 2011
2 min read

Hundreds of new and updated cars arrive in Australia each year but only one is good enough to make the honour role for Carsguide COTY.

This time around the prize fight is tougher than ever, with new arrivals for 2011 covering every size and price class, from the ordinary Chery J1 from China to the exotic Ferrari 458 Italia from Italy. Neither of them makes the COTY cut, but that's another story ...

The reach for COTY 2011 contenders actually stretches back to the final months of last year, to include a couple of cars that just missed the 2011 cutoff, and this time around the newcomers must have hit showrooms by December 1.

So, unfortunately, the all-new Toyota Camry is a non-starter. It's the same for the make-or-break four-cylinder Falcon.

But the class of 2011 covers all the bases, from affordable mini cars through family and prestige cars to a hot new coupe. The hopefuls come from Europe, Asia and Japan, as well as right home in Australia.

Setting the field for 2011 was not easy, particularly with the outgoing champion - the Volkswagen Polo - still casting a considerable shadow.

But each of the COTY judges, who cover the Carsguide contenders and drive them in all conditions from coast to coast, has called up their personal favourites from Alfa Romeo through to Volkswagen to help guide the selection process.

Then it is the final cull by the COTY veterans to produce the top 10 for a gruelling two-day shootout to consider everything from design and safety through to value and their driving ability on a wide range of roads from Ford's You Yangs proving ground to freeways, suburban streets and gravel roads on the outskirts of Melbourne.

The field is set, the race is about to be run, but we cannot get ahead of ourselves.

So here are the 10 COTY contenders ... now it's over to the judges:

BMW 1 Series
Ford Focus
Ford Territory diesel
Holden Cruze
Hyundai i40 Tourer
Kia Rio
Nissan Micra
Range Rover Evoque
Volkswagen Scirocco
Volvo S60 T4.
Paul Gover
Paul Gover is a former CarsGuide contributor. During decades of experience as a motoring journalist, he has acted as chief reporter of News Corp Australia. Paul is an all-round automotive expert and specialises in motorsport.
About Author

Comments